6

MBA 15" good enough?

 1 year ago
source link: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/mba-15-good-enough.2398501/
Go to the source link to view the article. You can view the picture content, updated content and better typesetting reading experience. If the link is broken, please click the button below to view the snapshot at that time.
neoserver,ios ssh client

MBA 15" good enough?

VirtuallyInsane

macrumors 6502

Original poster

Nov 16, 2018
Is the MBA 15" 16/512 worth it/ sufficient enough:

- For a light and portable laptop.
- To do some light video editing.
- To do some music making (DAWs like FL Studio, Reason 12 and Audacity etc).
- For decent, all-day battery life.
- For a good screen for video watching.
- For opening 50 tabs on Firefox.
- For doing some writing on Pages/Word
- For doing some editing on Sheets.
- For streaming online (Hyperbeam).
- For eBook Reading.
- For streaming music
- To not spend a lot of money on overkill specs.
- For someone on a budget.

If not, what else do you recommend?

superamit

macrumors member
Mar 9, 2011 Brooklyn, NY
The macbook 15 air is not a budget computer; it's a premium product. All that stuff you listed, the air will perform fine.

Andeddu

macrumors 65816
Dec 21, 2016 1,398 1,728
Even an M1 MBA would tick all those boxes. You'll have plenty power to play around with if you get the M2 MBA.

1BadManVan

macrumors demi-god
Dec 20, 2009 2,967 3,049 Bc Canada

VirtuallyInsane

macrumors 6502

Original poster

Nov 16, 2018
Yes. It's great. Just get it; you'll be happy.
Thanks, I'm definitely looking into it soon.
The macbook 15 air is not a budget computer; it's a premium product. All that stuff you listed, the air will perform fine.
Yes, I know that it is a Premium Product, but compared to the MBP, it's still touted as "the budget option" on the website (well the more budget-friendly, cheaper one). But thanks. I will look into it soon.
Even an M1 MBA would tick all those boxes. You'll have plenty power to play around with if you get the M2 MBA.
I guess so but I'd like a bigger screen than the 13". I currently have a 13" laptop, and I like it enough, but 15" would be a nice upgrade and sweet spot.
Easily handle all of that and doing it silently
Oh, that's great. I want it to be silent
Reactions: mr_jomo and Andeddu

SAdProZ

macrumors 6502a
Mar 19, 2005
With my M2 MacBook Air, I do everything you do and more and it's never slowed down, not once.

50 tabs in Firefox would need approximately 8.5 GB of RAM (give or take a couple GB). You will have 16 GB and so that is sufficient. Purchase with confidence.

ArkSingularity

macrumors 6502a
Mar 5, 2022
Pretty much all of the Apple Silicon models are absolute screamers in terms of performance. Any of them will fit the bill for what you're planning to do with it.

If you plan on doing heavy multitasking, I'd probably go for the 16GB model (as @SAdProZ mentioned). 8GB will still get the job done, but some of these workloads are the kinds of workloads where you'll probably have a much better experience with 16GB (video editing and audio work especially, although Logic is pretty lightweight if you're using the stock plugins. It's third party stuff that gets heavy quickly).
Reactions: Tagbert and SAdProZ

Totally Bored

macrumors member
Jun 29, 2015
I'm sure it will do all that and then some.

For $300 more you can get a MBP14"
Reactions: mojo50

ilikewhey

macrumors 68040
May 14, 2014 3,492 4,474 nyc upper east
For a good screen for video watching.
that really depends on the individual, having being spoiled by the mini led on my mbp 14 and ipad pro i can't go back to regular lcd on the mba.
For opening 50 tabs on Firefox.
assuming you got nothing else open in the background, like literally nothing else.
To not spend a lot of money on overkill specs.
you already speccing it to the base mbp 14 price range, whether you consider it overkill spec no one can really answer that for you.
Reactions: 1BadManVan

throAU

macrumors G3
Feb 13, 2012 8,374 6,396 Perth, Western Australia
Is the MBA 15" 16/512 worth it/ sufficient enough:

- For a light and portable laptop.
- To do some light video editing.
- To do some music making (DAWs like FL Studio, Reason 12 and Audacity etc).
- For decent, all-day battery life.
- For a good screen for video watching.
- For opening 50 tabs on Firefox.
- For doing some writing on Pages/Word
- For doing some editing on Sheets.
- For streaming online (Hyperbeam).
- For eBook Reading.
- For streaming music
- To not spend a lot of money on overkill specs.
- For someone on a budget.

If not, what else do you recommend?
You could do all that on a base model iPad.

Yes, it's overkill.

GaryGnu

macrumors member
Nov 6, 2019
Just picked up a 15" 16G 1TB.
Works like a champ.
No issues with screen after comparing it side by side with a 16 (and a 14). While I would have liked the 16, the 14 was too small and the extra bit of screen wasn't worth it for the price difference, in my opinion. I know...machine lasts 5 years, so its 5-7 a month if you want to spread it out, but I didn't want to.

Plus, I loaded Windows 11 in a UTM VM and it ran all the Windows software I needed, plus still had memory to spare.

Only thing I don't like is the spacing between the keys. I'm used to a keyboard with a wider spacing. I'll get used to it though, I did last time I used a macbook keyboard.
Reactions: VirtuallyInsane

VirtuallyInsane

macrumors 6502

Original poster

Nov 16, 2018
Thanks for your replies, everyone.
With my M2 MacBook Air, I do everything you do and more and it's never slowed down, not once.

50 tabs in Firefox would need approximately 8.5 GB of RAM (give or take a couple GB). You will have 16 GB and so that is sufficient. Purchase with confidence.
Yes, my current MBP has 8GB and it needs a bit more RAM than that. The storage is fine and it runs alright, but I want more RAM without the overkill Pro specs.
Pretty much all of the Apple Silicon models are absolute screamers in terms of performance. Any of them will fit the bill for what you're planning to do with it.

If you plan on doing heavy multitasking, I'd probably go for the 16GB model (as @SAdProZ mentioned). 8GB will still get the job done, but some of these workloads are the kinds of workloads where you'll probably have a much better experience with 16GB (video editing and audio work especially, although Logic is pretty lightweight if you're using the stock plugins. It's third party stuff that gets heavy quickly).
I'm sure it will do all that and then some.

For $300 more you can get a MBP14"
I know that, but it's kinda getting into "do I want that thicc thing in my backpack?" territory.
that really depends on the individual, having being spoiled by the mini led on my mbp 14 and ipad pro i can't go back to regular lcd on the mba.
I don't care so much for screens when my iMac is 5K, and this thing has a clear enough image. But that's fair enough. You have your reasons.
you already speccing it to the base mbp 14 price range, whether you consider it overkill spec no one can really answer that for you.
But it depends on where you get it from. And I know this sounds really superficial, but I'm dying to get my hands on that Midnight shade. I am so sick and tired of space grey, and grey. I want something darker.
You could do all that on a base model iPad.

Yes, it's overkill.
Yeah, but it's not a Macbook lol. I have an iPad but I use it mainly for reading things.
Just picked up a 15" 16G 1TB.
Works like a champ.
No issues with screen after comparing it side by side with a 16 (and a 14). While I would have liked the 16, the 14 was too small and the extra bit of screen wasn't worth it for the price difference, in my opinion. I know...machine lasts 5 years, so its 5-7 a month if you want to spread it out, but I didn't want to.

Plus, I loaded Windows 11 in a UTM VM and it ran all the Windows software I needed, plus still had memory to spare.

Only thing I don't like is the spacing between the keys. I'm used to a keyboard with a wider spacing. I'll get used to it though, I did last time I used a macbook keyboard.
Yes, exactly what I am looking for. I'm looking for the portability of the Air, but a bigger screen and if it's powerful enough to run a VM on, then it will be good enough to run some DAW editing on it. I have a MBP 13" (8GB, got it for a good price a few years back) and it runs alright, but I think the bigger screen and the extra 8GB RAM will help me out.

I did think about the 14"/16" MBP, but it does seem overkill. Unless there was one on offer for an amazing price, then I am probably not going for that, to be honest. Nothing wrong with it, but it does seem very powerful. I'm not a professional who needs all those specs (I say, typing from the base model MBP, lol, which in fairness is more like a new MBA from what I can tell).

SAdProZ

macrumors 6502a
Mar 19, 2005
Then it’s settled then: you’re getting the 15.5-inch MacBook Air with M2 chip, 16 GB RAM, and Midnight color.

There’s no detriments to your pick. Everything about it is amazing. Just buy it already and then tell us about it. We want a testimonial.
Reactions: VirtuallyInsane

profH

macrumors member
Jun 16, 2017 Pasadena, CA
Then it’s settled then: you’re getting the 15.5-inch MacBook Air with M2 chip, 16 GB RAM, and Midnight color.

There’s no detriments to your pick. Everything about it is amazing. Just buy it already and then tell us about it. We want a testimonial.
SAdProZ, what configuration of MBA 15 do you have?

About Joyk


Aggregate valuable and interesting links.
Joyk means Joy of geeK