Wright v McCormack: UK Court of Appeal sides with Peter McCormack in damages row
source link: https://coingeek.com/wright-v-mccormack-uk-court-of-appeal-sides-with-peter-mccormack-in-damages-row/
Go to the source link to view the article. You can view the picture content, updated content and better typesetting reading experience. If the link is broken, please click the button below to view the snapshot at that time.
Wright v McCormack: UK Court of Appeal sides with Peter McCormack in damages row
Business 26 July 2023
The U.K. Court of Appeal has ruled that the trial judge in Wright v McCormack was legally entitled to award only nominal damages to Dr. Craig Wright, despite finding that Peter McCormack had caused serious damage to his reputation. Previous cost orders demanding that McCormack pay Dr. Wright’s pre-trial costs, which are expected to be more than £1 million, are unaffected.
Dr. Wright won against Peter McCormack at a trial for defamation back in 2022 over a series of publications the blogger had made on social media calling Dr. Wright a fraud. At trial, McCormack did not argue that his statements were true, which would have afforded him a full defence if accepted by the court. Ultimately, the court found that McCormack was liable to Dr. Wright for defamation.
However, trial judge Justice Chamberlain only awarded nominal damages of £1 to Dr. Wright. This was due to an argument which Dr. Wright abandoned before trial that McCormack’s statements had caused him to be disinvited to a series of conferences. McCormack’s lawyers later introduced evidence during trial which cast doubt over whether this had happened. Even though Dr. Wright never advanced the argument at trial, Justice Chamberlain found that Dr. Wright had originally intended to advance a deliberately dishonest case which justified an award of nominal damages.
As the appeal only concerned whether the judge was entitled to award nominal damages under the law, the Lord Justices of the Court of Appeal were not permitted to examine whether there was a basis for Justice Chamberlain’s findings as to Dr. Wright’s alleged dishonesty. Their finding was merely that an award of nominal damages was permitted under the law.
In a statement, Dr. Wright said:
“I am very disappointed that the Court of Appeal has not given due recognition to the damage caused to me by orchestrated online vitriol. Such abusive communications, viewable worldwide, have had a severe impact on me and my wellbeing. The trolling narrative is purely designed to unfairly and improperly denigrate my life’s work. McCormack was wrong in his tweets and video when he said that I am not Satoshi Nakamoto – and as such has caused me harm both personally and professionally.
“So, given the finding of serious harm, I am disappointed that the compensatory damages due from McCormack remain diminished – not for their monetary value but for the message this sends to potential future perpetrators of detrimental mistruths online.”
New to blockchain? Check out CoinGeek’s Blockchain for Beginners section, the ultimate resource guide to learn more about blockchain technology.
Recommend
-
34
Bitcoin podcasterPeter McCormack has sought for a deadline extension to file his defense against thelibel claims filed by Dr. Craig Wright. The host of the What Bitcoin Did podcast initially had until June 13 to...
-
4
Peter McCormack legal team reappears in pre-trial hearing Business 18 February 2021...
-
3
Peter McCormack’s last chance to appeal rejected, trial to begin in May Business 2 February 2022 The U.K. Court of Appeal ha...
-
3
Peter McCormack quits Twitter ahead of Craig Wright defamation verdict Business 7 hours ago
-
13
Wright v McCormack Day 2: Blogger Peter McCormack grilled on deleted evidence Business 2 hours ago Peter McCormac...
-
8
Wright v McCormack concludes on Day 3 as both sides make closing arguments Business 3 hours ago The
-
7
Craig Wright vs Peter McCormack analysis Editorial 15 August 2022 Because so much of the media has been talking a...
-
5
What does the Peter McCormack verdict mean for Granath v Wright? Business 7 hours ago Last month, the English Hig...
-
6
UK Court of Appeal hears Wright v McCormack trial judge is not entitled to reduce damages Business 16 June 2023 The English Court of...
-
5
UK Court of Appeal rules Craig Wright’s copyright claim over Bitcoin file format can proceed Business 20 July 2023 Dr. Craig Wright...
About Joyk
Aggregate valuable and interesting links.
Joyk means Joy of geeK