AI poisoned its own well, libraries to UnsuckJS, we need more Richard Stallman...
source link: https://changelog.com/news/50
Go to the source link to view the article. You can view the picture content, updated content and better typesetting reading experience. If the link is broken, please click the button below to view the snapshot at that time.
Transcript
Changelog
Click here to listen along while you enjoy the transcript. š§
What up, nerds?
Iām Jerod and this is Changelog News for the week of Monday, June 26th 2023. Hey that sounds familiarā¦
Hello, friends. Iām Jerod and this is Changelog News for the week of Monday, June 27th 2022. What the what?
That was me one year ago this week. Thatās right, Changelog News is a one-year old! Cool Cool Cool.
Letās get into the news.
Hereās a quick clip of me and Simon Willison talking Stable Diffusion back in September of 2022:
Thatās oh so relevant today because of a new study on AI model collapse that says āWe find that use of model-generated content in training causes irreversible defects in the resulting models, where tails of the original content distribution disappear. We refer to this effect as Model Collapse and show that it can occur in Variational Autoencoders, Gaussian Mixture Models and LLMs.ā
Tracy Durnell writes that she believes AI has already poisoned its own well. āI suspect tech companies (particularly Microsoft / OpenAI and Google) have miscalculated, and in their fear of being left behind, have released their generative AI models too early and too wide. By doing so, theyāve essentially established a threshold for the maximum improvement of their products due to the threat of model collapse. I donāt think the quality that generative AI will be able to reach on a poisoned data supply will be good enough to get rid of all us plebsā
Since thereās no consistent system for marking up generated content online as computer generated, the toothpaste is already being squeezed from its proverbial bottle. Hereās Tracy again:
Because of this approach, 2022 and 2023 will be essentially ālost yearsā of internet-sourced content, even if they can establish a tagging system going forward ā and get people hostile or ambivalent to them to use it.
If sheās right, this is a big deal.
UnsuckJS.com is a cool microsite from Adam Hill that catalogs the many (20+) JavaScript libraries that progressively enhance HTML and cost 10KB or less to deliver to your clients. No build tools, no compilers, and no hassle.
Iād love to see this resource go beyond the basic information and table format it currently has. But still, Iām a big proponent of this āless JSā movement and there are some high quality libraries featured here (and some Iād never heard of!). having them all in one place is a win.
We need more of Richard Stallman, not less. Thatās the title of a recent article by Ploum (a.k.a. Lionel Dricot). After a big fat disclaimer differentiating the manās philosophy from the man himself, he writes: āRMS was right since the very beginning. Every warning, every prophecy realised. And, worst of all, he had the solution since the start. The problem is not RMS or FSF. The problem is us. The problem is that we didnāt listen.ā
The core of Stallmanās beliefs were the four freedoms of software. The right to use the software at your discretion. The right to study the software. The right to modify the software. And The right to share the software, including the modified version.
These four freedoms were formalized as copyleft, but according to Ploum RMSās theory had a weakness in that copyleft itself wasnāt part of the four freedoms it secured. This allowed other non-copyleft licenses to come along and secure all four. Thereās too much said to quote it all on the show, so read the piece which includes Ploumās suggested amendment (one obligation) to RMSā four freedoms of free software.
Then let me know what you think in the comments. Was RMS right? Did we just not listen? Would Ploumās amendment fix things? Iād love to hear your thoughts on the matter.
Itās time for some Sponsored News!
Just because you donāt record a problem doesnāt mean it didnāt happen.
Stay ahead of latency issues and trace every slow transaction to a poor-performing API call or database query. Sentry is the only developer-first application monitoring platform that shows you whatās slow, down to the line of code. But donāt take their word for it. Matthew Egan (Engineering Team Lead at DiviPay) has this to say about it: āUnlike past tools weāve used, Sentry provides the complete picture. No more combing through logs ā Sentry makes it incredibly easy to find issues in our code to deliver a much smoother payment experience and a better overall customer experience.ā
Check the link in the show notes and get a demo today. Why not, right?
Can you trust ChatGPTās package recommendations? Maybe not so much. The team at Vulcan have published a new security threat vector theyāre calling AI package hallucination. It relies on the fact that ChatGPT (et al) sometimes answers questions with hallucinated sources, links, blogs and statistics. Itāll even generate questionable fixes to CVEs and offer links to libraries that donāt actually exist!
āWhen the attacker finds a recommendation for an unpublished package, they can publish their own malicious package in its place. The next time a user asks a similar question they may receive a recommendation from ChatGPT to use the now-existing malicious package. We recreated this scenario in the proof of concept below using ChatGPT 3.5.ā
Be careful out thereā¦
That is the news for now!
On Wednesday Iām talking yak shaves, system architecture, -10x devs & more with Taylor Troesh. And on Friday Kelsey Hightower joins Adam and I on Changelog & Friends!
Have a great week, share Changelog with your peers who might dig it & Iāll talk to you again real soon.
Changelog
Our transcripts are open source on GitHub. Improvements are welcome. š
Recommend
-
275
Trusted Reviews is supported by its audience. If you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a commission.
-
96
Richard Stallman, a.k.a. rms, discusses free software, data collection, privacy, and why he wonāt use cash when he goes shopping.
-
84
-
47
My Lisp Experiences and the Development of GNU Emacs (Transcript of Richard Stallman's Speech, 28 Oct 2002, at the International Lisp Conference). Since none of my usual speeches have anything to do...
-
7
Info ...
-
11
Richard Stallman - "The state of the Free Software movement" - April 13, 2022Free Software founder has choice words for Ubuntu, Apple. Announces a manual for GNU C.On April 13th, 2022, Richard Stallman ā founder o...
-
5
Richard Stallman Calls for Software Package Systems that Help Maintain Your Freedoms Slashdot is powered by your submissions, so send...
-
3
Richard Stallman č°č®ŗčŖē±č½Æ件čæåØēē°ē¶
-
1
We need more of Richard Stallman, not less by Ploum on 2023-06-19...
-
1
Richard Stallman's political discourse on sex November 25, 2023 on Drew DeVault's blog Richard Stallman, the founder of the Free Software...
About Joyk
Aggregate valuable and interesting links.
Joyk means Joy of geeK