2

If you think Bluesky is decentralized, you’ve been conned

 1 year ago
source link: https://blog.wesleyac.com/posts/bluesky
Go to the source link to view the article. You can view the picture content, updated content and better typesetting reading experience. If the link is broken, please click the button below to view the snapshot at that time.
neoserver,ios ssh client

If you think Bluesky is decentralized, you’ve been conned

Apr 28, 2023

Bluesky is a purportedly-decentralized social media company that spun out of Twitter, beginning in 2019. It makes sense that people are hunting for new social media platforms right now — Elon Musk's disastrous takeover of Twitter has demonstrated how fragile relying on private VC-funded companies is for something so critical as communication infrastructure. BlueSky's answer to this is that they are decentralized — thanks to the AT Protocol, anyone can run a server. Unfortunately, it's decentralized in name only:

  • The AT Protocol is entirely controlled by Bluesky the company, with no community governance structure or plans for a governance structure. Want to change how it works? Tough luck, buddy.
  • Want to run a server yourself? Well, the server is closed-source, so you'd better enjoy reimplementing it all yourself.1 (Edit: I'm told that this is not true, and that the atproto has the server code. However, it's unclear to me how much of what's running on bsky.social is public — the identity parts appear to be, but not the web frontend, that I can find.)
  • The apps? Also closed source, you don't have any control over them.2

This isn't how you build a decentralized ecosystem, it's how you build a system that you can claim is decentralized while still holding all the power yourself.

There's a lot more that's wrong with Bluesky that I'm not going to get into, since I honestly don't really care. But if you care about not giving more power in your life to a VC-funded company started by a guy who said that "Elon is the singular solution I trust" to running Twitter, you probably want to stay away from Bluesky.


  1. You might reasonably be fooled into thinking that indigo is the server, but a closer look reveals that this does not seem to be the case. 

  2. There does appear to be one open-source Android app from a third-party, but there doesn't seem to be any plan to open-source the official apps. 


About Joyk


Aggregate valuable and interesting links.
Joyk means Joy of geeK