Folklore.org: Do It
source link: https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&story=Do_It.txt
Go to the source link to view the article. You can view the picture content, updated content and better typesetting reading experience. If the link is broken, please click the button below to view the snapshot at that time.
Folklore.org: Do It
Author: Andy Hertzfeld
Date: June 1982
Characters: Larry Tesler
Topics: User Interface, Software Design, Lisa
Summary: User testing sometimes has surprising results
Many of the academic types who were involved in creating the earliest implementations of the graphical user interface at Xerox PARC and various universities sort of sneered at the first generation of personal computers when they appeared in the mid-seventies, since the early personal computers were much less powerful than the machines that they were used to programming. There wasn't that much you could do with only four kilobytes of memory and no disk drive.
But Larry Tesler, who was a key member of the Smalltalk team in the Learning Research Group at Xerox PARC, felt differently. He was really excited by the potential of personal computers, buying a Commodore PET as soon as one became available in 1977. He was one of the demonstrators at Apple's famous Xerox PARC visit in December 1979, and he was so impressed by the Apple visitors that he quit PARC and started working at Apple on July 17, 1980, as the manager of the Lisa Applications team.Larry championed consistency between applications, and made many contributions to what eventually became the Macintosh User Interface. He was also the leading advocate and implementor at Apple of user testing: actually trying out our software out on real users and seeing what happened. Starting in the summer of 1981, Larry organized a series of user tests of the nascent Lisa software, recruiting friends and family to try out the software for the first time, while being observed by the Apple designers who recorded their reactions.
The user tests were conducted in a specially constructed room featuring a one-way mirror, so observers could watch the tests without being intrusive. The tests were conducted by a moderator who made sure the user felt comfortable and showed her the basics of using a mouse. Then, with no further instruction, users were asked to perform specific tasks, without help from the moderator, like editing some text and saving it. The moderator encouraged each user to mumble under her breath while doing the tasks, revealing her current thinking as much as possible. Each session was audio or videotaped for later analysis.
When the software required confirmation from the user, it displayed a small window called a "dialog box", that contained a question, and presented two buttons, for positive or negative confirmation. The buttons were labeled "Do It" and "Cancel". The designers observed that a few users seemed to stumble at the point that the dialog was displayed, clicking "Cancel" when they should have clicked "Do It", but it wasn't clear what they were having trouble with.
Finally, the team noticed one user that was particularly flummoxed by the dialog box, who even seemed to be getting a bit angry. The moderator interrupted the test and asked him what the problem was. He replied, "I'm not a dolt, why is the software calling me a dolt?"
It turns out he wasn't noticing the space between the 'o' and the 'I' in 'Do It'; in the sans-serif system font we were using, a capital 'I' looked very much like a lower case 'l', so he was reading 'Do It' as 'Dolt' and was therefore kind of offended.
After a bit of consideration, we switched the positive confirmation button label to 'OK' (which was initially avoided, because we thought it was too colloquial), and from that point on people seemed to have fewer problems.
Recommend
-
92
Introduction JAQS是一个开源量化策略研究平台,由交易专家和金融技术专家共同设计,实现了自动化信号研究、高效策略开发和多维度回测分析,支持Alpha、CTA、套利等策略的实现。JAQS从实战而来,经实盘检验,本地化开发部署,保障策略安全。
-
54
Org Edna Copying Copyright (C) 2017-2020 Free Software Foundation, Inc. This program is free software: you can redistrib...
-
107
-
630
-
13
If you do web development, you've probably used console.log at least once (or over a thousand times...who's cou...
-
10
News » News & Analysis » 3D computer vision startup Visionary Machines raises $7.5 million seed round...
-
4
A Mac For Mick A Mac For Mick Author: Andy Hertzfeld Date: January 1984 Characters: Bob Belleville, Steve Jobs, Lynn...
-
4
OpenBSD folklore and share/misc/airport OpenBSD's share/misc/airport file and a day trip to Lublin June 8, 2022 · 2 min Back in 2016, I sent a
-
2
Folklore.org: Switcher Switcher Author:...
-
2
HorrorThe Many Horrors of an Icelandic ChristmasSorry, Krampus, there’s a new yuletide terror in town—several of them, in fact....
About Joyk
Aggregate valuable and interesting links.
Joyk means Joy of geeK